Your Questions for the Author Answered

January 26th Question

I saw your post regarding the dearth of fantasy/sci-fi books. Specifically the list on Amazon. I just finished reading Titanium Noir by Nick Haraway and I think you might find it very entertaining. Of course, you might have read it already! I’m a big fan and thank you for all of your works.

Thank you. I’ll have to take a look at Titanium Noir.

January 20th Question

I have been unable to find the answer to my question: How does the United States “transparently convey” to the American public what it should in order to allow the people to effectively govern the nation”? Can you suggest a reference, or example from your experience in government, how our representatives and government agencies can and do communicate with us other than via the media? Should the President and our individual representatives use TV/radio on a regular basis to notify the public of relevant practical, ethical, legal news (sort of a fireside chats? Or perhaps DOGE can use Transforming Government for the 21st Century?

Some members of Congress have always made an effort to communicate to their constituents on important issues. One member for whom I worked sent out regular newsletters. Another did short television presentations on issues. The underlying problem is that, in a nation as large and complex as the United States, the number of issues — and the associated complexities — makes communicating on all of them virtually impossible. I was once asked to explain an environmental issue — the tradeoffs between two approaches of meeting wastewater effluent discharge standards — and before I’d finished two sentences, I was told not to “deliver a long-winded epistle,” even though the trade-offs involved hundreds of millions of dollars for the manufacturing plants involved.

People want simple answers. Simple answers are ALWAYS misleading, often deceptive, and also often inaccurate. But people tune out long explanations.

In a representative democratic republic (which is what the U.S. effectively is) the best solution is to elect good, knowledgeable leaders, and for the federal government departments and agencies to hire good competent people. Despite all the bad press, federal departments and agencies actually have done a remarkable job over the years.

The more urgent problem is that in electing public officials, usually the best public presenter wins the election, and all too often the best public speaker is neither good nor that knowledgeable a leader.

January 16th Question

I’ve always wondered, with your massive collection of written works, has there ever been a proposition for a movie and/or series? (I’m biased for the Corean Chronicles but, just imaging a war torn Alucius firing a darkened bullet into a diving pteirodon on the big screen, got me wondering.) Also, the art for your covers are phenomenal, and belong in a museum, how did you acquire these master artists? Is it a certain institution or was it all via commission/freelance?

So far, while I’ve had occasional inquires from the movie/cinema field, no one has ever made even a proposition for a movie or TV production/series. The artwork for my covers was handled by the art department at Tor, and, as you’ve noted, in general they’ve done a very good job, especially with the fantasy covers, although some of the SF covers are among my favorites (Haze, Archform:Beauty, Quantum Shadows).

January 14th Question

I went to Barnes and Noble to buy the book Overcaptain in Gilbert, AZ. They had 4 of your books on the shelf, one hardback, four paperback, all of which I have. Why don’t they have more of your books?

The short answer is greed and algorithms. The long answer is more complex, and involves a number of factors. Back in the 1990s, B&N bookstore managers could actually stock books that better fit their clientele. Now, from what I understand, that’s difficult, if not impossible. Beginning in the 1980s, the IRS applied the Thor Power Tools decision to book publishing, which made it unprofitable for publishers to keep large backlists in stock in their warehouses. Then, with the rise of Amazon, B&N further reduced the amount of books stocked in stores, and buyers in bookstores can’t buy what’s not there. More important, they often don’t know what’s missing. In the 1990s, B&N stores often carried the entire Recluce series. That enticed readers. But today, B&N relies on algorithms to predict sales of books, even before they’re published, based in large part on sales of the previous book by that author. But for authors like me, that’s deadly and misrepresentative, because readers are still purchasing books I wrote thirty years ago. So B&N orders books based on the last book, rather than on my total sales in the past year, and they don’t re-order when they run out, which makes increasing sales difficult, and why your local B&N doesn’t carry more of my books — and why Amazon and other booksellers get a larger share of my sales every year.

January 9th Question

Why are you using such an odd tense in From The Forest, etc.? I think you used it in other narratives too. I find it strange to read neither here nor there. I can find no reference to it anywhere. Did you create this idea yourself?

The tense I used in writing From the Forest is known as the “present tense.” I certainly didn’t invent it. It’s always been part of the English language, but the majority of English/American fantasy and science fiction is written in the simple past tense. I chose the present tense as a way of keeping the action and thought close to the present and the character.

December 28th Question

I know this is a bit personal but how do you pronounce your name. Is it Mo-desitt Mod-esitt or Mode-sitt Over here in the UK I’ve heard all three variations and as I have pretty-well every book you’ve written over the past forty odd years when I first met your books in a San Francisco book shop I’d really like to get it right.

It’s pronounced MODD (rhymes with “odd”) — ess — it. Of course, the way the family pronounces our name breaks every pronunciation rule, which might be why others have a problem with it.

December 17th Question

Still reading; hope you’re still writing?

I’m still writing, and there are three books scheduled over roughly the next 20 months: Sub-Majer’s Challenge in August 2025; Legalist in October 2025; and Last of the First in mid 2026.

December 16th Question

Why did the Recluce marines attack Lerris and Tamra at the end of The Death of Chaos? Lerris had literally just defeated the attacking Hamorans, so I can’t really follow the reasoning.

Earlier in the book there are sections mentioning Heldra and the black squads. They were opposed to Lerris coming to Recluce in the first place, and they believed, accurately, that even if Lerris prevailed, Recluce would be devasted (and they’d lose everything, which they pretty much did). So it’s not surprising that they attacked at the end.

December 10th Question

How far in advance do you plan the Recluce books? Did you already have Nylan’s story worked out when you wrote The Magic of Recluce? What about Cerryl’s story from Colors of Chaos when you wrote The Magic Engineer?

As I’ve written elsewhere, I wrote The Magic of Recluce as a singleton just to prove that I could write a fantasy. I had no plans at all for a sequel, let alone a series. So when David Hartwell asked for another Recluce book, I initially had a hard time coming up with The Towers of the Sunset. In any book I write, however, I put in bits of past history, because every viable culture has a past, and this habit/tool has allowed me to weave together the histories within the world of Recluce. Even well before I finished The Magic Engineer, I was thinking about how Justen ended up where he did and about Fairhaven and how it had to be more than just power-hungry white wizards.

November 30th Question

In view of this article: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/11/democrats-defined-progressive-issues/680810/ – perhaps this is a way to rebalance US ideologies if the democratscan avoid the label of socialist progressives i.e. democrats? The Federalist Party was a conservative and nationalist American political party and the first political party in the United States. It dominated the national government under Alexander Hamilton from 1789 to 1801. The party was defeated by the Democratic-Republican Party in 1800. Democratic-Republican Party (also referred to by historians as the Jeffersonian Democratic Party), was an American political party founded by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison in the early 1790s. The party became increasingly dominant after the 1800 elections as the opposing Federalist Party collapsed/disappeared. Increasing dominance over American politics led to increasing factional splits within the party. Old Republicans, led by John Taylor of Carolina and John Randolph of Roanoke, believed that the administrations of Jefferson, Madison, and Monroe, and the Congresses led by Henry Clay, had in some ways betrayed the republican “Principles of ’98” by expanding the size and scope of the national government. The Republicans splintered during the 1824 presidential election. Those calling for a return to the older founding principles of the party were often referred to as “Democratic Republicans” (later Democrats) while those embracing the newer nationalist principles of “The American System” were often referred to as National Republicans (later Whigs). So I thought an answer to the article by Eliot Cohen in the Atlantic: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/11/guide-politically-homeless-2024-election/680795/ would be to accelerate the split in the present Republican Party and form a Federalist, National Democratic, or Conservative political party. However: it looks like the international oligarchs are way ahead of me: the broligarchs are distinct from old-school American oligarchs in one key respect: Their political vision seeks to undermine the nation-state system globally. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/11/broligarchy-elon-musk-trump/680788/ What would Alyiakal or Dekkard do?

Both Alyiakal and Dekkard take steps to restrict the power of the plutocrats, Dekkard within the confines of the law (if barely), while you’ll have to wait to see what Alyiakal does in dealing with the power of the traders.

November 25th Question

Unlike all previous books in the Saga of Recluce, the newest book, Overcaptain, does not have a whispersynced version of Audible. Why? It’s got the Audible versions but it’s not whispersynced with the kindle version.

I’m afraid I can’t answer that question. That’s something between Tantor, Audible, and Amazon.

November 18th Question

Just wondering why there aren’t any maps in From the Forest or Overcaptain? Is this your choice, or Tor’s? I enjoy your writing, and the world you’ve created in Recluce.

As I’ve mentioned elsewhere, I submitted updated rough maps to Tor, i.e. annotated versions of older maps. I was told that the combination of copyright on the original maps and cost to redraw them made including them infeasible.

November 2nd Question

Is there an upcoming book in The Grand Illusion? It just seems to stop.

The fourth book in The Grand Illusion is Legalist, which is a prequel to the first three books. Right now, I don’t wish to say more about possible future books.

October 11th Question

I would appreciate any comments you may have about the politics and economics of this article: https://www.foreignaffairs.com/world/age-depopulation-surviving-world-gone-gray-nicholas-eberstadt

My initial reaction is that Eberstadt totally misses the ramifications of the most important point. We’re seeing depopulation because women everywhere in the world are tired of being baby factories and being marginalized. Where they can, they’re stepping away from familial structures that continue to minimize them. Where they can’t step away, they’re trying to have fewer children.

Until men and governments recognize this, and actually deal with the problem, it’s going to continue.

October 3rd Question

I wondered if you ever considered a Prequel series to the “Forever Hero” novels. It seems like the downfall of Earth, and how Gerswin came to be.

I’ve never considered a prequel to The Forever Hero for several reasons. First, such a prequel would be a real downer. Second, for it to be even halfway realistic, the books or books would have to be massive. Third, the last kind of book I’d want to write would be a massively complex downer, especially since The Forever Hero is essentially a tragedy.

September 23rd Question

I enjoy your writing and own most of your books, which I buy new because I like to support writers. Being on a retirement budget, I wait patiently for the Mass Market Paperback editions, which also fit on my shelves. However, the prices on your recent series have been rapidly climbing. Mass Market Edition of Contrarian at $15.00??? Is your publisher trying to encourage us to turn to the resale market?

No… Tor isn’t trying to cut readership. It’s a sad fact, but inflation has also hit publishing costs. I understand your amazement and frustration, but it’s not just Tor. Contrarian runs 750 pages in the mass market edition. I’ve done a spot check of current mass market paperbacks of approximately the same length as Contrarian, and I’ve found quite a few, from various publishers, in the $13.00-$15.00 range. There are several reasons for that. First, the price of paper and everything else is up. Second, the overall sales of mass market paperbacks have dropped enormously, most likely because ebooks cost less. As a result, for better or worse, from here on out, it’s unlikely that any of my upcoming releases will be available in mass market paperback. The only print versions will be hardcover and trade paperback.

The problem is that I write large books. Large books have lots of pages, which requires more paper. Almost all of the recently published mass market paperbacks around the same length as Contrarian that I could find (and there weren’t many) are priced in the same range. The vast majority of books listed in Locus are half the length of Contrarian in hardcover and sell for about $5-$7 less. If I didn’t sell reasonably well in ebooks, I doubt that Tor could afford to publish my long novels in print format at all.

I realize that’s hardly comforting to you, and it’s certainly not to me, but the way matters are going, according to many professionals throughout the field, fewer and fewer books, especially long ones, will be printed or reprinted as mass market paperbacks because the physical production costs have increased so much. It also means that I won’t be writing really long books and/or they’ll have to be split into more volumes.

September 18th Question

Firstly, your books have brought me great enjoyment, in particular Corean Chronicles, Imager Portfolio and Saga of Recluse. I was delighted to find a chronology for Recluse on your site and am now in the midst of rereading all of them in order (barring the few that are not yet published). However there is a small inconsistency – Wellspring of Chaos, Year 2170, is followed by Ordermaster, Year 2112. Are the years wrong, or are the books in the wrong order?

Alas, it’s more mundane than that. It’s a typo. The year for Ordermaster should have been 2172 (I’ve since changed it on the website). Thank you for bringing it to my attention.

September 3rd Question

This isn’t much of a question, but more of an adoration for your work! I had ZERO idea my favorite author of the last few years has a slick website, and an active response series! I’ll be brief, but as a sophomore at KSU (Go Cats!), your mass portfolio of novels, alongside your battle depictions and determined characters have me hooked–and honestly, amazed. (Man is THE writer). It’s taken me a while, but I’ve been reading The Corean Chronicles, and I’m currently on the second half of the second book, Darknesses, and Alucius (the GOAT) has just awoken from his near-death battle with the Pteranodons, ending the war with a new expanse of his talent. My question goes into the motive/mentality of Alucius at this point; with the the mass loss/Burning of his men, repeated omen-induced dreams, and a horribly injured body (poor guy got his hair burnt off)–Does he, behind the pages, experience anguish over being used by the Dekrons? Or more so, feels disgust in how easy it is for himself to kill? (luckily it’s always in defense!) If translated such events in today’s world, would Alucius ever be expected of showing symptoms of shell-shock, PTSD? Some passages hint to his withdrawn attitude when ever (briefly) saying what cruelties happened to him to his spouse (in Legacies), but he more-so, just shares a small nod and a send-off in relation to his under captains/soldiers. Therefore, is it because of his herding-origins and strength in The One who Is, that Over Captain Alucius doesn’t shy away from calculated killing? (I don’t want to compare two giants of fantasy literature, but I only know that much) Like Froddo’s dread of the ring, does Alucius carry his talent with a sense of horror? (Being that, many officers would be alive with him, but literal cities would’ve been ablazed if it wasn’t /for/ him). I ask this because, seeing him be used by those torque-wielding women in the last book, I catch myself wondering if the heralded hero ever hesitates, or in such a state of war, there’s no time to hesitate. Maybe I’ll eat my words come chapter 78, but I’m too excited to send a message to the AUTHOR HIMSELF!

For better or worse, you did send a message to the author himself, since I’m the only one responding or posting from the website. In answer to your question about Alucius’s mental state, from my observations and limited research into possible PTSD-inducing situations, there are two primary factors affecting susceptibility to PTSD: (1) the intensity or horror of the events experienced (including duration and closeness) and (2) the individual’s resilience and ability to remain less attached (the “problem” being that I suspect total detachment borders on psychopathy). Alucius never wanted to be a soldier/warrior; he’s a nightsheep herder, and he ends up being good at what he does by first just surviving, and second, by recognizing that the only way he’ll ever be able to return to what and who he loves is by destroying what stands in the way in the most effective manner (which is in fact borderline psychopathy) and by, in effect, identifying those behind his opponents as “the other,” which is a traditional coping mechanism of human beings forced to do horrific acts.

I won’t comment further because Scepters will bring Alucius another trial.

August 23rd Question

Will there be any additional Imager books after Endgames?

It’s highly unlikely, but I won’t absolutely foreclose the possibility. At this point, I’ve written five fantasy series and three science fiction “series” (linked books in different futures), and I still am writing, with three more Recluce books and at least one more, and possibly two Grand Illusion books coming out in the next three years. While I intend to keep writing, I’m not exactly a spring chicken, as the old saying goes, and we’ll just have to see.

Second August 22nd Question

I noticed an error at page 601, line 16 of Contrarian. The word “kept” should have been “keep.”

Despite intensive proofreading, typos still slip in. I’ve passed the error on to Tor.